Both golfers finished at even-par (144) for the 36-hole tournament and helped the Flying Dutchmen place second out of 16 teams at Bedford Valley Country Club.
On Saturday, Settecerri shared low-round honors for the Flying Dutchmen with a 73.
Two teammates also chipped in 73s like the sophomore from Bloomfield Hills, Michigan (Bloomfield Hills HS): juniors Josh Gibson of Grandville, Michigan (Grandville) and Ben Kramer of Spring Lake, Michigan (Spring Lake).
Gibson (145) tied for seventh place. Kramer (151) tied for ninth.
Sophomore Noah Weigle of Grandville, Michigan (Grandville) also played in Hope's top group and tied for 41st (158).
Individually, junior Andrew Goble of Brighton, Michigan (Brighton) shot his second consecutive 75 of the tournament. He tied for 16th.
Freshman Jacob Thomson of Beaver Dam, Wisconsin (Central Wisconsin Christian) shot a 74.
Freshman Jason Deans of Arlington Hills, Illinois (John Hersey) had a final-round 82.