Updated thru 2019 season
| Coach | Seasons | W-L-T | Pct. | MIAA Titles |
| Phil Van Eyl | 5 (1963-67) | 16-19-2 | .432 | |
| Bill Vanderbilt, Sr. | 2 (1968-69) | 9-11-0 | .450 | |
| Gene Brown | 3 (1970-72) | 23-14-0 | .622 | 2 (10-5-0) |
| Glenn Van Wieren | 8 (1973-79, 88) | 55-67-7 | .454 | 1 (37-30-5) |
| Gregg Afman | 5 (1980-84) | 59-23-6 | .705 | 2 (43-11-4) |
| Todd Kamstra | 3 (1985-87) | 28-19-4 | .671 | 0 (22-11-3) |
| Todd Winkler | 1 (1989) | 6-10-2 | .389 | 0 (4-8-0) |
| Steven Smith | 28 (1990-2017) | 372-154-44 | .691 | 9 (254-95-25) |
| Dave Brandt | 2 (2018-) | 28-9-2 | .744 | 0 (10-3-1) |
