Note: In 2024, All-America honors were extended to include second-team honors for those finishing ninth through 16th at the NCAA Division III Championships.
2025 Josh Bordovsky, Everett Cox, Graham Eisenmann, Joe Engle, Conner Halberg, Colin Kalkman, George Marsh, Luke Newcomb
2024 Henry Booker, Ben Catton, Graham Eisenmann, Christian Hoeksema, Colin Kalkman
2020 Gabe Boonstra, Daniel Clyde, Daniel Keith, Bailey Smith
2010 Phil Heyboer
2008 Phil Heyboer, Brandon King, Ryan Nelis, Matt Rose
2007 Phil Heyboer
2006 Kurt Blohm, Chas Vanderbroek, Ryan Vogelzang, Jeff Vroegindewey
2005 Travis Barkel, Kurt Blohm, Abram Glas, Jeff Heydlauff
2004 Kurt Blohm, Chris Hamstra, Jeff Heydlauff, David Ornee
2003 Travis Barkel, Chris Hamstra, Jeff Heydlauff, David Ornee, Brian Slagh
2002 Josh Boss, Daniel Bouwens, Tim Dehaan, Chris Hamstra, Jeffrey Heydlauff, Ian Kobes, Brian Slagh, Jeff Vroegindewey
2001 Josh Boss (NCAA Division III Swimmer of the Year, Chris Dattels, Tim Dehaan, Chris Hamstra, Ian Kobes, Brian Slagh, Scott Vroegindewey
2000 Josh Boss, Tom Bouwens, Chris Dattels, Jarod Lippert, Brian Slagh, Scott Vroegindewey
1999 Josh Boss, Tom Bouwens, Chris Dattels, Joshua Ficke, Jarod Lippert
1998 Troy Aumaugher, Chris Dattels, Dan Daly, Joshua Ficke, Jarod Lippert, Dan Shelley
1997 Derek VanderHeide
1996 Shawn Kinser, Jens Milobinski, Keith Nykamp, Dan Shelley, Bob Springsteen, Derek VanderHeide
1995 Kirk Assink, Aaron Hoffman, Matt Hollebeek, Shawn Kinser, Dan Knapp,, Jack Methric, Jens Milobinski, Keith Nykamp, Derek VanderHeide
1994 Kirk Assink, Brad Genson, Matt Hollebeek, Aaron Hoffman, Steve Hope, Andrew Johnson, Shawn Kinser, Dan Knapp, Jack Methric, Keith Nykamp
1993 Kirk Assink, Jeff Bannink, Brian Bollone, Brad Genson, Jon Hescott, Steve Hope, Shawn Kinser, Dan Knapp, Jack Methric, Keith Nykamp
1992 Jeff Bannink, Jon Hescott, Matt Hollebeek, Steve Hope, Jack Methric, Phil Sotok, Chris Von Ins
1991 Jeff Bannink, Brian Bollone, Matt Dahl, Brad Genson, Jon Hescott, Steve Smant, Phil Sotok, Chris Van Ins
1989 Jim Mitchell
1987 Rob Peel
1986 Rob Peel
1985 Rob Peel, Tim Dykema, Rex Romano, Pete Tilden
