Note: In 2024, All-America honors were extended to include second-team honors for those finishing ninth through 16th at the NCAA Division III Championships.
2025 Emme D'Errico, Greta Gidley, Katie Hermann, Sara Kraus, Lauren Ryle, Bella Turner, Laurel Wasiniak
2024 Greta Gidley, Katie Hermann, Sara Kraus, Lauren Ryle, Delaney Wesolek
2023 Greta Gidley, Sara Kraus
2022 Sara Kraus
2020 Emma Schaefer
2019 Meg Peel
2016 Sarah Sheridan
2015 Sarah Sheridan
2014 Sarah Sheridan
2008 Brittaney Reest
2007 Laura Ansilio, Trisha Meier, Claire Piester, Brittaney Reest, Lisa Smith, Christina Vogelzang
2006 Laura Ansilio, Lisa Ekdom, Trisha Meier, Brittaney Reest, Lisa Smith
2005 Lisa Ekdom, Trisha Meier, Lisa Smith, Erika Steele
2004 Audrey Arnold, Lisa Ekdom, Haley Martin, Lisa Smith, Michelle Smith, Sarah Smith, Erika Steele
2001 Betsy VandenBerg
2000 Colleen Doyle, Llena Durante, Kari Jackson, Laura Smith,Betsy VandenBerg, Erinn VanAuken
1999 Jenna Anderson, Colleen Doyle, Llena Durante, Kari Jackson,Erinn VanAuken, Betsy VandenBerg, Liz Vanderveen
1998 Katie Baumann, Kara Binkley, Llena Durante, Laural Horton,Monica Stubbs, Erinn VanAuken, Betsy VandenBerg
1997 Amy Bos, Lindy Chelf, Llena Durante, Megan Hunter, Adrienne Prince, Melissa Thiel, Erinn VanAuken
1996 Lindy Chelf, Dawn DeBoer, Dana Horner, Kristen Hoving,Megan Hunter, Teresa Kirkland, Kari Jackson, Nicole LamkeyDenice Masselink, Simone Scher, Melissa Thiel
1995 Lindy Chelf, Dawn DeBoer, Dana Horner, Kristen Hoving,Megan Hunter, Teresa Kirkland, Nicole Lamkey, Denice. Masselink, Simone Scher, Melissa Thiel
1994 Sarah DeWitt, Dawn Hoving, Kristen Hoving, Dana Horner, Megan Hunter, Teresa Kirkland, Susan Looman, Sara Looman, Denice Masselink, Jennifer Noorman
1993 Monica Bullard, Dawn DeBoer, Dawn Hoving, Kristen Hoving, Teresa Kirkland, Denice Masselink, Michelle Mojzak, Jennifer Noorman
1992 Kristy Achterhof, Amy Bongers, Monica Bullard, Sarah DeWitt, Dawn Hoving, Jennifer Noorman
1991 Kristy Achterhof, Jilanne Bannink, Sarah DeWitt, Lori Gano, Dawn Hoving
1989 Kristy Achterhof, Jilanne Bannink, Elizabeth Becker, Shelly Russell, Kirsten Van Overen
1988 Kristi Achterhof, Jilanne Bannink, Elizabeth Becker, Lori Gano,Karla Koops, Shelly Russell, Jennifer Straley, Diane Vos
1987 Karla Koops, Mary Lynn Massey, Shelly Russell,Jennifer Straley, Kirsten Van Overen
1986 Kaarli Bergman, Karla Koops, Connie Kramer, Karen Rubin, Shelly Russell, Jennifer Straley
1985 Kaarli Bergman, Jane Houting, Connie Kramer,Jennifer Straley
1984 Charlotte Johnson, Connie Kramer, Susan Solmen, Sarah Souter, Irene Wang
1982 Leslie Bethards , Lynn Bufe, Neddie Haven, Janet Howat, Lisa Kortering, Kirsten Newhof, Nancy Scholten, Sarah Stanwood
