Note: In 2024, All-America honors were extended to include second-team honors for those finishing ninth through 16th at the NCAA Division III Championships.
Total All-America (Individual and Relay)
18 Jon Hescott, 91-93 (7 individual, 11 relays)
17 Josh Boss, 99-02 (8 individual, 9 relays)
14 Jeff Bannink, 91-93 (6 individual, 8 relays)
13 Kirk Assink, 93-95 (7 individual, 6 relays)
12 Tim DeHaan, 01-02 (4 individual, 8 relays)
11 Brian Slagh, 00-03 (4 individual, 7 relays)
11 Shawn Kinser, 91-96 (1 individual, 10 relays)
10 Chris Dattels, 98-01 (1 individual, 9 relays)
10 Jack Methric, 92-95 (4 individual, 6 relays)
10 Rob Peel, 1985-87 (8 individual, 2 relays)
Individual All-America
8 Josh Boss, 99-02
8 Rob Peel, 85-87
7 Kirk Assink, 93-95
7 Jon Hescott, 91-93
