Note: In 2024, All-America honors were extended to include second-team honors for those finishing ninth through 16th at the NCAA Division III Championships.
50 Freestyle
4th  Susan Looman, 1994
4th  Erika Steele, 2004
5th  Erika Steele, 2005
6th  Erinn VanAuken, 1998
6th  Erinn VanAuken, 1999
7th  Erinn VanAuken, 2000
100 Freestyle
5th  Jennifer Straley, 1988
5th  Erinn VanAuken, 1997
5th  Erinn VanAuken, 1999
6th  Jennifer Straley, 1986
6th  Erinn VanAuken, 1998
6th  Erika Steele, 2004
6th  Erika Steele, 2005
7th  Sarah DeWitt, 1992
7th  Erinn VanAuken, 2000
9th Laurel Wasiniak, 2025
14th Greta Gidley, 2025
15th Greta Gidley, 2024
200 Freestyle
1st  Shelly Russell, 1988
1st  Shelly Russell, 1989
2nd  Shelly Russell, 1987
3rd  Kristen Hoving, 1995
3rd  Erinn VanAuken, 1999
4th  Jennifer Straley, 1987
6th  Jennifer Straley, 1986
7th  Shelly Russell, 1986
7th  Sarah DeWitt, 1991
16th  Laurel Wasiniak, 2025 (Second Team)
500 Freestyle
1st  Shelly Russell, 1987
1st  Shelly Russell, 1988
1st Shelly Russell, 1989
1st  Kristen Hoving, 1996
2nd  Kristen Hoving, 1995
3rd  Shelly Russell, 1986
3rd  Jennifer Straley, 1987
3rd  Kristen Hoving, 1993
3rd  Kristen Hoving, 1994
8th  Jennifer Straley, 1986
1650 Freestyle
1st  Shelly Russell, 1987
1st  Shelly Russell, 1988
1st  Kristen Hoving, 1995
2nd  Kristen Hoving, 1994
2nd  Kristen Hoving, 1996
3rd  Shelly Russell, 1986
3rd Shelly Russell, 1989
3rd  Kristen Hoving, 1993
200 IM
2nd  Dawn Hoving, 1993
2nd Greta Gidley, 2024
2nd Greta Gidley, 2023
3rd  Betsy VandenBerg, 2000
4th Greta Gidley, 2025
5th  Sara Looman, 1994
5th  Llena Durante, 1998
6th  Dawn Hoving, 1994
7th  Betsy VandenBerg, 1999
8th  Dawn Hoving, 1992
15th Katie Hermann, 2024
*Â Â Emma Schaefer, 2020 (NCAA Championships not held)
400 IM
3rd  Kristen Hoving, 1994
100 Butterfly
1st  Dawn Hoving, 1993
2nd  Dawn Hoving, 1992
2nd  Dawn Hoving, 1994
2nd  Llena Durante, 1998
3rd  Lisa Smith, 2006
4th  Lisa Smith, 2005
6th  Llena Durante, 2000
6th  Lisa Smith, 2007
8th  Sara Looman, 1994
11th Greta Gidley, 2024 (Second Team)
200 Butterfly
1st  Dawn Hoving, 1992
1st  Dawn Hoving, 1993
2nd  Dawn Hoving, 1994
2nd  Kristen Hoving, 1996
7th  Lisa Smith, 2006
8th  Dawn Hoving, 1991
100 Backstroke
1st  Susan Looman, 1994
2nd  Sara Looman, 1994
2nd  Laural Horton, 1998
5th  Brittaney Reest, 2006
6th  Lori Gano, 1991
7th Sara Kraus, 2022
8th  Brittaney Reest, 2008
200 Backstroke
1st  Susan Looman, 1994
2nd Meg Peel, 2019
3rd Laural Horton, 1998
4th Sara Kraus, 2025
5th Sara Kraus, 2022
7th Sara Kraus, 2023
10th Sara Kraus, 2024
100 Breaststroke
2nd  Betsy VandenBerg, 2001
3rd  Betsy VandenBerg, 2000
3rd  Meghan Hunter, 1995
4th  Meghan Hunter, 1994
200 Breaststroke
1st  Betsy VandenBerg, 2000
1st  Betsy VandenBerg, 2001
2nd  Meghan Hunter, 1995
2nd  Betsy VandenBerg, 1998
2nd  Betsy VandenBerg, 1999
One-Meter Diving
3rd  Sarah Sheridan, 2016
3rd  Sarah Sheridan, 2015
5th  Kari Jackson, 1999
5th  Kari Jackson, 2000
7th  Sarah Sheridan, 2014
Three-Meter Diving
1st  Sarah Sheridan, 2016
2nd  Sarah Sheridan, 2015
7th  Sarah Sheridan, 2014
200 Medley Relay
1st  1994
3rd  1996
3rd  1997
3rd  1998
4th  1999
4th  2000
7th  1995
10th 2025
11th 2024
400 Medley Relay
1st  1994
3rd  1998
3rd 1999
4th  1995
4th  1996
5th  1997
6th  1993
6th  2000
7th  1992
8th 2025
12th 2024 (Second Team)
200 Freestyle Relay
2nd  1994
4th  1989
4th  1998
5th  1988
5th  1997
5th  1999
6th  1991
6th  1996
6th 2025
7th  1992
7th  1993
7th  1995
7th  2004
7th  2005
15th 2024
400 Freestyle Relay
2nd  1988
3rd  1994
4th  1989
4th  1992
5th  1995
5th  1997
5th  2004
5th  2006
6th  1987
6th  1993
6th  1998
6th  1999
6th  2007
7th  2000
7th 2025
8th  1986
8th  2005
800 Freestyle Relay
3rd  1988
4th  1986
4th  1989
4th  1992
4th  1994
4th  1995
5th  1987
5th  1991
5th  1996
5th  1998
7th  1993
8th  1985
8th  2007
12th 2025
