* Voted MIAA Most Valuable Player
2024 Abby Fansler
2021 fall Megan Jenkinson, Grace VanDellen*
2021 spring Megan Jenkinson, Abigail Meder
2017 Megan Klintworth*, Jordyn Rioux
2016 Britni Gielow, Nicole Meyer
2015 Britni Gielow, Megan Klintworth, Nicole Meyer
2014 Britni Gielow, Megan Klintworth*, Morgan Leep
2012 Brittany Haight, Charlotte Park
2011 Brittany Haight, Charlotte Park
2008 Megan Scholten
2007 Julie Hoogerhyde
2005 Brittanny Philo
2003 Lacey Wicksall
2002 Emily Colenbrander
2001 Lacey Wicksall
2000 Lacey Wicksall*
1999 Ellen Colenbrander*
1998 Ellen Colenbrander*, Gina Pellerito
1997 Ellen Colenbrander
1996 Ellen Colenbrander,* Nancy Kennedy, Gina Pellerito
1995 Gina Pellerito
1994 Kristen Cline, Nancy Kennedy
1993 Nancy Kennedy*, Lisa Stover
1992 Lisa Stover*
1991 Lindsay Munson, Lisa Stover*
