All-Time MIAA Tournament record is 49-49 (.500) through the 2025 season.
Hope vs. Adrian - Hope 7-7
Hope vs. Albion - Hope 9-1
Hope vs. Alma - Alma 16-10
Hope vs. Calvin - Calvin 12-10
Hope vs. Kalamazoo - Hope 1-0
Hope vs. Olivet - Hope 5-0
Hope vs. Saint Mary's - Hope 5-3
Hope vs. Trine - Trine 11-2
2025
Adrian 3, Hope 1
Hope 9, Calvin 5
Trine 5, Hope 2
2024
Calvin 3, Hope 2
Hope 5, Adrian 2
Calvin 3, Hope 0
2022
Calvin 3, Hope 0
Hope 8, Alma 3
Hope 9, Calvin 6
Trine 6, Hope 1
2021
Adrian 5, Hope 1
Hope 7, Albion 0
Hope 5, Adrian 2
Calvin 5, Hope 1
2020
Season canceled due to COVID-19 pandemic
2019
Calvin 8, Hope 2
Hope 5, Trine 4
Saint Mary's 6, Hope 4
2018
Calvin 3, Hope 1
Hope 12, Alma 4
Hope 4, Calvin 1
Hope 6, Saint Mary's 2
Hope 4, Saint Mary's 2 (champions)
2017
Trine 5, Hope 3
Saint Mary's 7, Hope 1
2016
Hope 3, Trine 2
Alma 2, Hope 1
Trine 8, Hope 0 (5)
2015
Alma 5, Hope 0
Saint Mary's 7, Hope 3
2014
Hope 3, Olivet 1
Hope 15, Calvin 12
Trine 11, Hope 3
Trine 8, Hope 1
2013
Trine 2, Hope 1
Adrian 3, Hope 1
2012
Did not qualify
2011
Hope 9, Adrian 8 (8)
Trine 2, Hope 0
Alma 5, Hope 1
2010
Did not qualify
2009
Trine 9, Hope 3
Adrian 5, Hope 3
2008
Adrian 4, Hope 0
Hope 7, Saint Mary's 1
Hope 4, Adrian 0
Trine 5, Hope 3
2007
Trine 2, Hope 0
Hope 6, Saint Mary's 1
Alma 7, Hope 4
2006
Hope 5, Olivet 4
Hope 5, Saint Mary's 2
Alma 5, Hope 4
Hope 6, Alma 5 (champions)
2005
Calvin 1, Hope 0
Hope 7, Olivet 6
Calvin 5, Hope 3
2004
Alma 8, Hope 1
Hope 7, Calvin 5
Alma 6, Hope 2
2003
Did not qualify
2002
Hope 2, Albion 1
Hope 13, Calvin 3
Alma 4, Hope 2
Alma 7, Hope 3
2001
Albion 4, Hope 1
Adrian 6, Hope 0
2000
Hope 5, Albion 4
Alma 5, Hope 3
Hope 4, Albion 1
Alma 11, Hope 0
1999
Calvin 2, Hope 1
Hope 4, Olivet 1
Calvin 1, Hope 0 (9 innings)
1998
Hope 4, Calvin 3
Alma 7, Hope 0
Calvin 6, Hope 5
1997
Hope 14, Albion 6
Calvin 2, Hope 1
Hope 5, Adrian 4
Alma 2, Hope 0
1996
Hope 5, Kalamazoo 2
Hope 5, Calvin 3
Hope 12, Calvin 8 (champions)
1995
Hope 12, Albion 0
Hope 15, Adrian 3
Hope 2, Alma 0
Hope 3, Calvin 2 (champions)
1994
Hope 2, Albion 1 (12 innings)
Alma 7, Hope 0
Hope 5, Alma 2
Alma 5, Hope 2
1993
Hope 7, Olivet 0
Hope 3, Alma 0
Adrian 3, Hope 0
Alma 1, Hope 0
1992
Hope 3, Albion 0
Hope 8, Alma 4
Hope 9, Alma 1 (champions)
1991
Hope 6, Albion 2
Hope 5, Alma 0
Hope 1, Adrian 0
Hope 3, Alma 0 (champions)
