All-Time Football Overtime Games
Updated through 2024 season
In 1996, the NCAA instituted a tiebreaker system to be used in all games tied after four periods.
Overtime Games Played: 9
Record in Overtime Games: 5-4
One Overtime: 5-1
Two Overtimes: 0-3
Overtime against MIAA Opponents: 4-1
Overtime Games at Home: 2-2
Overtime Games on Road: 3-2
9-6-97
|
Valparaiso 35, Hope 34 (2ot), away |
|
|
End of regulation teams tied 21-21 |
|
First Overtime |
|
Hope - Justin Wormmeester, 1 run; Travis Williams, kick PAT |
|
Valpo - Bob Cracknell, 2 run; kick PAT |
|
Score remains tied 28-28 |
|
Second Overtime |
|
Valpo - Paul VanDam, 2 run; kick PAT |
|
Hope - Justin Wormmeester, 24 run; Travis Williams, PAT kick failed |
|
Valparaiso wins 35-34 |
|
|
10-24-98
|
Hope 43, Alma 37 (1ot), away |
|
End of regulation teams tied 37-37 |
|
Overtime |
|
Alma - failed to score |
|
Hope - Tim Alles, 13 yard pass from Justin Wormmeester |
|
Hope wins 43-37 |
|
|
9-11-99
|
Augustana 34, Hope 33 (2ot), home |
|
End of regulation teams tied 27-27 |
|
First Overtime |
|
Neither team scored |
|
Score remains tied 27-27 |
|
Second Overtime |
|
Augustana - Ben Nelson, 10 run; John Phillips kick PAT |
|
Hope - Eric Nichols, 13 run; PAT pass failed |
|
Augustana wins 34-33 |
9-16-00
|
Hope 30, DePauw 24 (1ot), away |
|
End of regulation teams tied 24-24 |
|
Overtime |
|
DePauw - failed to score (pass interception by Matt Bride) |
|
Hope - Mike Gle, 25 yard pass from J.D. Graves |
|
Hope wins 30-24 |
|
|
10-7-06
|
Hope 49, Alma 43 (1ot), away |
|
End of regulation teams tied 43-43 |
|
Overtime |
|
Hope - David Booko, 11 yard run (PAT kick failed) |
|
Alma - failed to scored (stopped on downs, incomplete pass on Hope 3) |
|
Hope wins 49-43 |
|
|
9-19-09
|
UW-Eau Claire 52, Hope 45 (2ot), home |
|
End of regulation teams tied 45-45 |
|
1st Overtime |
|
Hope - failed to score |
|
UW-Eau Claire - failed to score |
|
2nd Overtime |
|
UW-Eau Claire - David Goodman, 33-yard pass from Kyle Paulson; PAT, S. Jacobson, kick |
|
Hope - failed to score |
|
UW-Eau Claire wins 52-45 |
|
|
11-5-11
|
Hope 24, Adrian 21 (1ot), home |
|
End of regulation teams tied 21-21 |
|
Overtime |
|
Adrian - failed to score (missed field goal) |
|
Hope - Evan Finch kicks 20-yard field goal |
|
Hope wins 24-21 |
|
|
10-4-14
|
Albion 37, Hope 36 (1ot), away
|
|
End of regulation teams tied at 30-30 |
|
Overtime |
|
Albion - Michael Czarnecki 5 run, PAT, Cody Lehman, kick |
|
Hope - Robert Kish 1 run, PAT, blocked |
|
Albion wins 37-36 |
|
|
10-18-14
|
Hope 42, Olivet 35 (1ot), home |
|
End of regulation teams tied at 35-35 |
|
Overtime |
|
Hope - Taylor Brynaert 16 pass from Rob Kish, PAT, Aaron Mick, kick |
|
Olivet - Kirby Brook INT in end zone |
|
Hope wins 42-35 |