2024 Oatis Ackermann (dl), Tyler Amos (rb), Seth Luhmann (H-back), Caleb Paarlberg (dl)
2023 Oatis Ackermann (dl), Cole Harger (ol), Luke Marsh (ol), Darion Nundley (db)
2022 Terrell Harris (wr), Dylan Clem (ol), Cole Harger (ol), Luke Marsh (ol), Mohamed Kamara (lb)
2021 Dan Romano (rb), TJ McKenzie, Jr. (wr), Lou Baechler (te), Dyan Clem (ol), Toby Hulst (lb), Jeremiah Purnell (lb)
2019 Connor Mellon (rb), Cooper Cecchini (wr), Noah de Velder (ol), Brady Eding (ol), Jeremiah Purnel (lb)
2018 Mike Miklusicak (rb), Christian Bos (wr), Tim Ivery (ol), Mason Dekker (lb), Luke Beckhusen (db)
2017 Mason Opple (qb), Brandan Campbell (rb), Chris Leigh (rb), Jacob Pardonnet (db), Mason Rosado (db)
2016 Mike Miklusicak (rb), Zach Taylor (dl), Jacob Pardonnet (lb), Andy Lucas (db)
2015 Branon Parcell (ol), Colin Kelly (db), Dean DeVries (P)
2014 Aaron Mick (k)
2013 Michael Atwell (qb), Cal Livingway (ol), Tim Klaus (lb)
2012 Michael Atwell (qb), Shawn Jackson (rb), Taylor Brynaert (wr), Evan Finch (k), Reggie Duncan (rs)
2011 Shawn Jackdon (rb), Alex Doman (ol), Nate Jazwinski (lb)
2010 Jordan Morse (dl), Aaron Thompson (p)
2008 Kyle Dietrich (wr/rs), David DeBoer (te), Chris Batterbee (lb)
2007 Ben Smith (dl), Brent Jones (rb), Jake Manning (qb), Colin Bates (dl)
2006 Joe Hensel (ol), Doug VanEerden (wr), Derek Cooper (dl), Matt Erb (dl)
2005 Kevin VandenBosch (te), David Booko (rb), Joe Diekevers (db)
2004 Josh DeHaan (ol), Nathan Barnett (k), Paul Hoeksema (lb), Joe Diekevers (db), Seth Kovarik (p)
2003 Mike Verwys (ol), Scott Jeschke (te), Jeff Eldersveld (wr), Brian Fielhauer (db), Seth Kovarik (p)
2002 Josh Rumpsa (ol), Joel Solomon (wr), Phil Butler (qb), Andy Keller (dl), Josh Baumbach (lb), Matt Beaver (lb), Matt Baumbach (db)
2001 Brian Hammer (ol), Bill Crane (ol), Josh Rumpsa (ol), Mike Gle (wr), John Sloothaak (rb), Phil Butler (qb), Ryan Kerstetter (dl), Pat Warren (dl), Matt Beaver (lb), Vinnie Harambasic (db)
2000 Nick Kunnen (ol), Scott Langlois (rb), Andy Keller (dl), Kevin Kudej (lb), Josh Baumbach (lb)
1999 Dan Wegner (ol)m Scott Langlois (rb), John Dobbins (dl), Matt Bride (lb), Vince Scheffler (p)
1998 Tim Alles (wr), Dave DeHommel (db)
1997 Brad Bolton (wr), Lou Raj (dl), Adam Paarlberg (lb), Dave DeHommel (db), Josh Bruwer (p)
